RESTAURANT BUSINESS VALUATION
by Oanh Tran, MBA
The George Washington University
Before an investor acquires a restaurant business, he/she would have to perform two types of valuation: the first one is for the business itself, and the second one is for its real estate. According to industry experts, the ability to generate consistent profits will ultimately determine the worth of the restaurant’s operation in the marketplace. The four approaches to value restaurant businesses are as follows: asset-based valuation, capitalization of income valuation, cash flow based valuation and market valuation or multiplier method.
1. Asset-based valuation
Asset based valuation is not usually practical for restaurant valuation because food establishment is usually measured by the clientele it attracts, the quality and creativity of its kitchen staff and the management. Restaurant assets such as dining room tables and kitchen equipment usually have low liquidation value. In addition, perishable items such as food have low inventory value. However, an extensive wine collection of a French restaurant can be a valuable inventory. For franchise operations, intangibles - - trade names - - of popular establishments such as Hard Rock Café or Pizza Hut can be valuable assets. The valuation is measured as:
Value = Fair Market Value of Assets + Inventory + Annual Net Income + Intangibles
2. Capitalization of Income Valuation
Because it accounts only for past history and not for future performance, this method is best used for franchise restaurant businesses which usually have steady growth potential in earnings. The price of a franchise restaurant is equal to its current annual income capitalized with (divided by) a capitalization rate ranging from 9% for well-known franchised operations such as McDonald’s or Burger King to 11% for a lessor known chain food operation.
3. Cash Flow-Based Valuation
This is the most comprehensive method and it is based on the premise that the present worth of the business is the present value of all net free cash flows that the establishment will generate over its expected life.
4. Market Valuation or Restaurant Multipliers Method
This is the most frequently used method in the restaurant business where the value of the restaurant is derived from using an "industry average" sales figure as a multiplier. Sometimes, appropriate adjustments need to be made such as location of the business, the equipment age and the arm’s length transaction. Although this valuation formula is simplistic, it is widely used. For example,
Restaurant with proven franchise
(brand new equipment) 60% percent of annual gross revenues
Fast food restaurants
(no franchises) 40% percent of annual gross revenues
Valuation of the Real Estate
As mentioned above, the valuation of the real estate would also have to be performed for a more complete analysis. If the restaurant is in a good location, some restaurant owners look at the real estate that comes with the business as a primary component of the value. They figure a high traffic spot will eventually make the business prosper. There are two types of real estate interests:
1. Fee simple ownership: if the real estate is part of the sale, the purchaser should obtain from the local tax assessor’s office all previous property appraisals to gain some ideas of potential future increase in value. Alternative uses of the real estate based on existing zoning regulation should also be considered.
2. Leased fee interest: if the real estate is leased, the purchaser should carefully look at the remaining terms of the lease and find out the cost to renew it. Restaurants should have a minimum of 10 years remaining on its lease with an option for another 10 years. In certain instances, if the lease is long term (above 10 years) and below market rate, and the business is located in a heavy pedestrian traffic area, then the purchaser may turn around and sell the lease at a substantial profit to a national chain food. This is the case when the lease is worth more than the restaurant itself.
In addition to the above valuation methods, there are non-quantitative factors to consider when consider purchasing a restaurant. These factors are, but not limited to, transportation access, available parking, desirable neighborhood, zoning regulations such as ADA compliance, and non-compete clause.
Five Top Choices of Web Sites on Restaurant Valuation
1. http://www.cgmco.com/mcd2.htm.
This site assists McDonald’s restaurant franchisees to evaluate the worth of their store with the help of a proprietary software package that this company has developed.2. http://www.restaurantvalues.qpg.com/ Member of the National Business Web Site Directory, Restaurant Values offers business evaluation package for restaurants based on the three different approaches.
3. http://www.americanexpress.com/smallbusiness/resources/starting/valbiz.shtml
This site was created by the American Express Company to assist small business owners with their financial planning. They have a helpful article about business valuation.
4. http://www.ras2000.com/ published by the Restaurant Advisory Services acting as consulting services to the restaurant and hospitality industry.
5. http://www.restaurantreport.com/features/ft_valuation.html
This site emphasized the fair market value and the capitalization rate as the best methods for restaurant evaluation.