• Return to front page

  •  

    Critiques of Frederick Douglass' Work, from The Narrative to the North Star

    By: Elvia Christina Southerland, David Portnoy and Angela Goodman
    Picture of Frederick Douglass
    "Right is of no sex-Truth is of no color-God is the Father of us all, And all we are brethren."
    --The North Star, Frederick Douglass' Newspaper 1847


    • A brief biography of Frederick Douglass 
    • Some historical criticisms of Douglass' Narrative 
    • New criticisms of Douglass' work 
    • Frederick Douglass Links 
    • See the First edition of The North Star, Douglass's newspaper 

    • A brief biography of Frederick Douglass

      Frederick Douglass was born into the institution of slavery in 1817, in Tuckahoe, Maryland. Frederick Douglass did not know the exact date of his birth so he adopted February 14th, because his mother used to call him her "little valentine." Douglass knew very little about his mother since she was a field hand on the plantation some twelve miles away, and tragically she died when he was a very young boy. Douglass did not know who his father was, but it was rumored he was the son of his white slave master, Aaron Anthony.

       As a child, some cruel slaveholders mistreated him. At times, to keep from starving, he competed with his master's dog for table scraps and bones. In 1825, he was sent to serve as a houseboy in the home of Hugh and Sophia Auld in Baltimore, Maryland. Mrs. Auld grew fond of Douglass and decided to teach him how to read and write. When Mr. Auld discovered this, he soon put a stop to it; however, Douglass had already acquired enough to carry on by himself.

       In 1832, Douglass went back to the harsh life on the plantation in Tuckahoe. For years later, along with several other slaves, Douglass attempted to escape, however the attempt was unsuccessful because one of the slaves revealed their plan. Viewed as a "bad slave," Douglass was sent to Mr. Covey's plantation. Covey was deemed as the best slave breaker around, and he whipped and worked Douglass mercilessly. Douglass endured all the mistreatment until one day he could stand it no longer and fought back. Douglass calls his standing up to Mr. Covey a "glorious resurrection," where his manhood was reinstated. He was again sent to Baltimore, where he met Anna Murray, a free black woman, who gave Douglass enough love and encouragement for him to heighten his quest to be a free man. On September 3, 1838, Douglass dressed in a Sailor's uniform and carrying identification papers provided by a free Black seaman, managed to reach New York City. There he met David Ruggles, an Abolitionist, who sheltered Douglass and assisted him with his wedding plans. Douglass then changed his surname from Bailey to Douglass, married Anna Murray, and the couple then moved to New Bedford, Massachusetts.

       Douglass soon began frequenting Anti-Slavery meetings, and on one occasion was unexpectedly called to speak. In the presence of some of the prominent Abolitionist (William Lloyd Garrison, Wendell Phillips, and William Collins), Douglass told the story of his life and was immediately urged to become an Anti-Slavery lecturer.

       Douglass used his knowledge of the English language and his vivid imagination to de4scribe slavery. His speeches were so eloquent that the public began to doubt that he was ever a slave. Douglass showed his objection to this doubt by writing "The Narrative," in 1845. After publishing this account of his life, he fled to England, fearing that he jeopardized his freedom. With the aid of his friends, Douglass secured his freedom and launched his newspaper, "The North Star." His editorials targeted slavery, job discrimination against Blacks, and The Fugitive Slave Act of 1850. IN addition to these events, he published his autobiography, "My Bondage and My Freedom," in 1855.

       Douglass changed his belief from "moral suasion" to implementing active ways to show his convictions. He focused his attention Jim Crow laws, by entering restricted public places in which these laws were enforced. He aided fugitive slaves and used his printing shop as an Underground Railroad station. Douglass was impress4ed by John Brown in overthrowing the government. Douglass had to flee and go to Canada for several months because a warrant was issued for his arrest after authorities found out about his involvement with Brown.

       


      Some Historical Critiques of Douglass' Works

      Critiques of The North Star

       Frederick Douglass' weekly publication, The North Star, was well received by fellow newspapers. In one of the beginning issues of The North Star, there are several critiques about the budding weekly from different newspapers such as the Rochester Daily Advisor, New York Tribune, Christian Sentential and the Pennsylvania Freemen. They all welcome Frederick Douglass' creation and view the paper as a prominent tool in the abolition of slavery.

       Most of the papers feel the North Star can "break through the walls of prejudice" (Pennsylvania Freemen), by keeping readers aware of the indignities that occur in slavery. The Pennsylvania Freemen also urges black readers to subscribe to the weekly for their sake, as well as the longevity of the paper.

       Frederick Douglass is described as a "popular leaver in the cases of abolition" (Advent Horlanger). Most of the newspapers remark on Douglass' leadership role in the abolition of slavery, they seem to believe that with him at the head of The North Star many things will be accomplished by the new weekly (including the abolition of slavery).

       Most of the papers speak of Douglass' remarkable escape from slavery and how he has overcome great tragedy to lead the masses of his people. They all seem to feel that Frederick Douglass can improve the predicament of Black people in America. They feel that is an excellent "guide and advocate of freedom."

       Although all the papers welcome Douglass' new weekly, The Advent Horlanger, does not "coincide with the abolition views of the Star." Yet, they believe that everyone, including Black people should enjoy reading the paper and have a right to read it.

       Most of the papers wish Douglass much success with his paper as well as his fight for the abolition of slavery, especially fellow abolition newspapers like the Pennsylvania Freemen, which looks forward to working with the North Star to emancipate slaves in America. 

      emancipation

      Historical Critiques of The Narrative 

      Donald B. Gibson believes the distinction that Douglass makes between American Christianity and ideal Christianity is "logically nice," but is impossible. This distinction is made only on an assumption that those categories exist.

       Houston A. Baker describes "The Narrative" as showing the lonely side of Douglass. He believes that a suppression of his knowledge and the lack of humanity caused the trials and tribulations Douglass went through. Furthermore, the conclusion of the novel talks about the language of education that Douglass uses gives him a new experience. Baker also critiques the restrictions Douglass puts on himself. Baker notes the "hierarchy of preferences," when Douglass confronted by the system he chooses to use in the novel.

       Robert Burns Stepto talks of "The Narrative" as being more metaphorical than rhetorical. In addition to this, the authenticity of the narrative and moral energies help shape Douglass' voice in "The Narrative."

       


      Modern Critiques of Douglass' Narrative

      Frederick Douglass' narrative is one of the earliest and debatable pieces of writing by a former slave. His narrative has been acclaimed both for its accurate and moving portrayal of slave life and for its literary merit. Douglass' narrative has stood out to many critiques for a number of reasons; first, in addition to being an author, he was also well noted for his oratory skills, this helped catapult Douglass' fame as well as his reputation as a great leader, orator and author. The themes in his narrative transcend slavery and hit on much larger issues of freedom. It not only speaks of gaining freedom, but also what a person can aspire to despite the odds stacked against them. Also, throughout Douglass' narrative he appears to live in a solitary life, seemingly drifting through the world alone; however Douglass does have many meaningful interactions that shape him as a person, and his drive to be free. 

      Some of Douglass' interactions were meaningful, but not always pleasant. In his narrative Douglass speaks of an altercation he had with his master, Mr. Covey. Douglass describes his fight with Covey as a "glorious resurrection," in that his spirit is freed from slavery. This fight reinvigorated him to attain his freedom, and also showed him that he did have the power to resist what was seen as an omnipotent institution-slavery.

       Another central theme in Douglass' narrative is his quest for manhood. Even as a boy he saw manhood as the first step towards his freedom. The first critiques also saw this theme. Robert Burns Stepto noted that the narrative becomes, "far more metaphorical than rhetorical" (The Slave's Narratives, 226). As his struggle is often shown in a vacuum of society, meaning that unlike other narratives, it did not include numerous others in his struggle. Douglass' story often seems to be somewhat of a parable and less of a history.

       Douglass not only uses his manhood to attain his freedom but also literacy. As a child, Douglass felt he had no power over his life because he could. But when he gained the skill of reading he was able to take more control over his life and begin to lay the foundation for his freedom. Critic Houston A. Baker Jr. noted that, "the slave's expanding awareness of language and its capacity to carry him towards new dimensions of experience {shows the counterpoints of whites' assumptions of Blacks}" (The Slave's Narrative, 247). At the point where Douglass actually decides to go north to attain his freedom, he was in the proverbial tomb of slavery from which the only escape was to actually flee to the north. It can be noted that in the narrative the actual escape is hardly mentioned, and when it is, it's presented in much less detail than almost any other slave narrative of the time where freedom is the denouement of the book. Douglass' narrative presents a more holistic view of his life, in that he presents himself as a p0erso9 before, after and during slavery, whereas many slave narratives end with the author finally feeling like a whole person after their long endurance with slavery.

       Douglass also held a strong view on slavery and Christianity. Throughout his narrative he called out many slave masters as hypocrites who preached the kind and humane gospel of Christianity, yet they practically torture, raped and destroyed their fellow man that they consider slaves. Douglass defines slaveholders idea of Christianity as "slave holders religion," the religion that the masters of the plantation had. Douglass compared the slave holders treatment of their slaves with the demeanor they held in church justifying his conjecture that the slave holders were hypocrites and did not practice the pure and unadulterated word of God. Douglass however believed in the true meaning of Christianity, that you treat others, as you want to be treated.

       Douglass made poignant points about manhood, Christianity and literacy that helped the freedom bells ring for all mankind. He did so in a peaceful and Christian manner that was exemplary and repeated in later years by civil rights activist Martin Luther King. Douglass opened the eyes for many both black and white to the shadows and indignities that slavery cast on all that were involved with it. Through his hard work, dedication and sacrifice he helped bring an end to the demon of slavery. 


    • Frederick Douglass Links

      Text of Frederick Douglass' Narrative 

      Text of "My Escape from slavery" 

      Biography of Frederick Douglass 

      Letter from Douglass to his former master, Thomas Auld 

      Selected bibliography for Frederick Douglass 


      The North Star

      The North Star 


      Bibliography

      Almanac, Afro-American, "Biography of Frederick Douglass."(1996): 7 paragraphs.[On-line] Available: www.toptags.com/aama/bio/men/freddoug.htm File:bio 

      Davis, Charles T., Henry Louis Gates Jr. The Slaves Narrative.London:Oxford Press 

      Sundquist, Eric J., ed. Frederick Douglass: New Literacy and Historical Essays. Boston: Cambridge Press, 1990. 

      Pictures

      Picture of the Narrative: http://www.ggw.org.freenet/f/fdm/doug3.gif 

      Portrait of Douglass: http://frederickdouglass.org 

      Emancipation proclamation: http://www.philaprintshop.com/images/eman.jpg